This article has mentions of products from one or more companies, and I may receive compensation if you purchase those products following reading my recommendations.

Investing in a diamond often represents a significant commitment, where the reputation of the brand can provide a reassuring sense of security. Typically, well-established companies are motivated to preserve their reputation to ensure continued customer trust and future business success.

Helzberg Diamonds boasts over a century of experience in the diamond retail industry, offering an expansive selection of engagement rings, wedding bands, and other fine jewelry including earrings, necklaces, and bracelets. Their move into modern retail is marked by a sleek website that effectively captures the essence of romance and luxury synonymous with their brand.

However, while Helzberg Diamonds may have a longstanding history, prospective buyers should approach with caution. The company's notable lack of transparency regarding diamond certifications and the absence of real diamond images on their platform are significant red flags. These shortcomings raise concerns about the quality and authenticity of their offerings, leading us to advise against purchasing from them.

Helzberg Diamonds Review

Helzberg Diamonds asserts that 'many' of their diamonds are graded by renowned third-party laboratories, including the AGS, GIA®, and GCAL. However, the use of the term 'many' instead of 'all' is concerning. It is essential for consumers to know that every diamond they consider is evaluated by a reputable lab, ensuring the authenticity and value of their purchase are verifiable. This lack of universal certification undermines the trust and assurance that comes with knowing exactly what you are buying.

Screenshot of the diamond details section from Helzberg Diamonds' website for a round diamond solitaire engagement ring in 14K white gold, showing specifications but lacking any mention of diamond certification.

Helzberg Diamonds' product page lacks certification details, raising concerns about transparency and diamond quality assurance.

Further complicating matters, Helzberg Diamonds does not consistently disclose the specific laboratories that certify their diamonds on their product pages. This omission is problematic, as it leaves potential buyers uncertain whether a diamond is certified by a prestigious institution like the GIA, or if it lacks certification altogether. Such ambiguity makes it difficult for consumers to trust the grading and quality of the diamonds offered.

Additionally, Helzberg Diamonds does not sell loose diamonds, which means they do not provide photographs or videos of the actual stones. This practice is a significant drawback for buyers who prefer to see detailed visuals of the diamond's characteristics and quality before making a purchase. The absence of such imagery is another major red flag that suggests a lack of transparency and commitment to customer assurance.

Furthermore, they are lacking the diamond light performance images required to truly analyze the quality of a diamond. Make sure you read my article on diamond videos and images for more information on what diamond images you need, and which companies provide them.

Helzberg Signature Collection Diamonds: A Cautionary Note

Helzberg Diamonds markets its Helzberg Signature collection as a premium line, but it falls short in crucial areas of customer assurance and transparency. Notably, the product listings for these diamonds do not specify the type of certification each diamond has received, if any. This omission is particularly alarming for a collection that positions itself as top-tier, as the specific details of a diamond's certification are fundamental to verifying its quality and value.

Moreover, Helzberg Diamonds does not provide essential visuals such as light performance images or high-definition videos for the Signature collection. Such visuals are vital for online buyers to assess the aesthetic qualities and craftsmanship of a diamond. The absence of this detailed imagery significantly hampers the ability of customers to make informed decisions about their purchases.

Given these significant gaps in information and the lack of visual confirmation of the diamonds' qualities, it is advisable to exercise caution. We recommend exploring other options or purchasing in-store where direct verification is possible, rather than purchasing Helzberg Signature diamonds online.

Don’t get ripped off by diamonds that are nowhere near Hearts and Arrows quality, for high performing diamonds with all the reports and images head to Whiteflash and consider their A Cut Above Diamonds, James Allen will also provide them on request for some of their diamonds.

Helzberg Settings and Engagement Rings: Varied Options, Fundamental Concerns

Helzberg Diamonds offers a respectable variety of settings and styles in their engagement ring collection, catering to diverse tastes and preferences. The range includes everything from classic solitaires to more intricate designs featuring multiple stones and unique accents. This variety ensures that most buyers can find a design that resonates with their aesthetic preferences.

Screenshot of the

Helzberg Diamonds presents a diverse array of engagement ring styles, offering choices for every preference on their "Shop All Styles" webpage.

However, despite the decent selection of settings, the overarching concerns regarding the transparency and certification of Helzberg Diamonds' stones cast a significant shadow over their offerings. The lack of clear, consistent information about diamond certification and the absence of detailed visuals such as high-definition images or videos for online buyers are major red flags. These issues are crucial when considering the purchase of an engagement ring, as the quality and authenticity of the diamond are as important as the setting itself.

Given these concerns, it would be prudent for potential buyers to exercise caution. While the settings might appeal at first glance, the uncertainties surrounding the diamonds themselves suggest that exploring alternatives or opting for vendors with more transparent practices might be a wiser course of action.

Helzberg Pricing

Unsurprisingly, a purchase from Helzberg Diamonds will set you back quite a fair amount. In particular, their engagement rings can carry a hefty price tag.

What makes this price difficult to justify is the fact that, contrary to claims of excellence, their diamonds can vary wildly in quality, with better stones available at lower prices on websites.

In general, when you make a purchase from a retailer such as Helzberg Diamonds, you’re paying for the security of their reputation and the status that comes with the brand name, more than you are for the quality of your piece.

Returns and Guarantees

Like most online retailers, Helzberg Diamonds offer a 30-day returns policy, allowing you plenty of time to get your money back if you’re not satisfied with your purchase. They also offer a 1-year guarantee on manufacturing defects and the mounting of your jewelry.

However, this warranty does not cover accidental wear and tear, or abuse of jewelry. It is nowhere near as generous as other brands, which may offer lifelong complimentary cleaning and replacement services.

Should I buy from Helzberg Diamonds?

When considering whether to purchase from Helzberg Diamonds, there are several factors to weigh. On one hand, Helzberg has a long-standing reputation and offers a wide variety of engagement ring settings and jewelry styles, which might attract many buyers. Their website is well-designed, reflecting the luxury and romance traditionally associated with fine jewelry.

However, significant concerns overshadow these positives. The lack of transparency regarding the certification of their diamonds is a critical issue. The fact that not all diamonds are confirmed to be graded by reputable labs, combined with the absence of specific certification details and visual documentation like high-definition images or performance videos, undermines buyer confidence. These omissions make it difficult to verify the quality and authenticity of their diamonds, which are essential factors in purchasing decisions for such valuable items.

Given these considerations, it is advisable to approach Helzberg Diamonds with caution. Prospective buyers should prioritize vendors who provide complete transparency about diamond certifications and offer comprehensive visual representations of their products. For those committed to making an informed and secure diamond purchase, exploring other retailers might be a more prudent choice.

Rather than risking your investment with Helzberg Diamonds, we recommend considering Whiteflash for their superior quality and transparent certification process. Alternatively, James Allen and Blue Nile are also excellent choices, known for their reliable service and quality offerings. Explore these options to ensure a purchase that's as secure as it is splendid.